Ive read it all...and have been waiting...as I know all of you have
Well, my input...
Regarding the arguement that Nudity has a place in art. Artists shouldnt be censored, etc.
This site is not an "art" site. Its a fun contest where we start by manipulating an image we are given and doing it the best we can in a way that we enjoy and hope that others like it and vote. There are
millions of ideas you can use to accomplish this without including nudity or graphic violence or testing how far you can push the line.
This is not and "Artist's" forum.
Regarding the arguement that parents should police their kids more and "turn it off"
Its a photoshop community. Its a great idea for all ages. I have enough to monitor and "turn off" for my kids already. Why should I have to monitor a graphic arts website that is meant to be fun,a place to learn, a place to gather with others that have the same interst, a hobby. Id love it if my kids were interested in something like this and developed a talent for graphic design. I dont want to turn a site like this off for my kids.
Regarding the arguement that this is what we have moderators for. Its JMH's site.
I know from experience that there is no clear guideline for any of the mods to follow and this only causes more issues.
Scion, is right...unless someone of some responsibility for the site creates some guidelines that are a bit clearer, we will always have this problem. If we had this, there would be no strife, no arguements about appropriate content...people would come and stay if they agreed, or leave if they didnt.
Morbid Circle arts, stop acting all innocent. How many nude/obscene images have you had deleted in the picture association thread? in fact, if I remember correctly, your first warning came from Nancers directly in the thread. You should have gotten the "picture" then without needing an official warning. Suck it up and move on.
Go to any other general population website and post nudity, graphic launguage and violence and you'll end with the same result.
I think more people will leave, than join if this site becomes an "Adult" site. Any public website, not deemed pornographic or adult in nature wants to attact as large an audience as it can.
mere_artist wrote:
i apologize as well, although this site is getting a little to pc instead of psc for my tastes..blah blah blah
mere_artist, get over it. you've made around 10 comments per month since joining here. With such little interaction here, how can you really be concerned about the political correctness.
Queen La Tiff wrote:
Seamus was right--you can't legislate morality, especially on a global level.
are we really trying to enforce morality by saying no more nudity or graphic violence? whether "in defense of the kids" or not? I dont think so. Its a simple rule. It doesnt state that its morally unacceptable or indecent...just that it shouldnt be posted.
THERE! that should make a few people run the other way
I feel better though. thanks.