Regarding this contest: http://photoshopcontest.com/photoshop-contest/1340/three-dolls.html

Both were great chops, only one won.

How 'bout a rematch?

Bluesbro:


YerPalAl:

Those are two very good chop and I seriously don't understand the 20 votes gap between them. (Fugue face)

I voted for both in that contest. I voted this poll for YerPalAl since the quality of the pic is a bit better at the hands/arms. really not much difference.

Both are excellent and either would be deserving of the win. I agree that Al's is just a fraction of a smidge better, because:
a. It's a bit sharper
b. It follows the actual saying (see no evil, hear no evil, speak no evil).

edit: on second thought, bluefist is right...the lighting is a better match on bluesbro's. Darn, that's a tough call...as your mom would say, you're both winners to me.

They're both good.

The one that won the contest had a more realistic match with the lighting.

I think the right post ended up winning that day.

The important thing is for both artists to have a GREAT summer.

I think Al got them in the right order---???
see no evil
Hear no evil
Speak no evil......Right?

I thoght it's the same picture when I saw them first.

Al definitely got the order right-but i like the top one a little more because of the eyes of both dolls looking at the doll in the center-to me this just works better as an image-both superb chops tho-

I have no problem with Bluesbro coming out on top. It was a good contest and we both did well enough.

There will be other times and other contests and the competition will be just as tough.

Cheers mate.

Al's image is BIGGER. Therefore, it should have won.

Everyone knows bigger is better.

Huh? Isn't it?

Except in suppository type medications, of course!

bluesbro's red dressed doll has shaved her armpits, so it wins.

Wow, I'm in a poll ... what a long, strange trip it's been I won't vote, but just a few comments. First off I cannot understand the vote gap either, both chops rock (if I don't say so myself ... lol). Secondly, when I saw on the first day of posting that Al and I had done such a similar picture I figured we would rob each other of any chance to win this contest, so it was totally surprising when it did turn out the way it did.

Here is the problem I had with this contest in particular, but others as well I'm sure ... and perhaps this should have been the poll question. Since it ended in a vote tie, it is the picture that was posted first that wins. In this case I believe Buglover's picture was posted before mine (I may be wrong about this, but I believe that is was that way on the first day) but an edit was made that pushed it back in queue ... therefore mine appeared as if it was posted first. I believe there should be multiple winning entries if the voting ends up tied. After this contest I was actually going to contact JMH and ask him to give this contest to the Bug, because if he hadn't edited his entry he would have won by the present contest rules. In the end I was too busy with real life stuff to IM him, but that offer still stands. In the end the voting and contest stuff doesn't mean as much to me as it seems to mean to others, so I would gladly give it to the entry that should have rightfully won.

It is always about how you feel about your entry that counts. I was extremely happy with how I pulled this one off, and when I saw that one of the PSC choppers I really respect had the same idea I felt great ... knowing that if Al had that idea too that my idea didn't suck ... lol. Again, about the vote difference I'm not sure what to say, other than I know if certain pictures get on a roll and stay near the top that they can tend to garner votes throughout the contest, and maybe even get a late vote rush (which my pic did). All I can say is I voted for Al's, because great minds do think alike ... right bud