Goat1981
The other does a bit more with the source, I think... However, everything matches better here. The lighting is especially confusing in the other (i.e. the bear is glowing like it has a spotlight, yet the couch is not affected). Still a tough choice, as both are good images. I'm leaning this way.
billtvshow
Really weird entry. My biggest concern is the off perspective pool of green ooze. Otherwise, I like a lot of it. The other is executed well, but pales in comparison when effort is factored in.
Trann
I like the other's intent but I find the limit use of the source to be a detraction: it seems surrender was in the air? This one refaces all blocks but could have coloured/lit them to match the existing paint/tones. Unsure why the "blood"(?) is green...
Pearcinator
Dont quite understand what the hell is going on with this one but I think it uses the source in a better way. The other entry is ok but it was clear that the source was an afterthought.
Adobe, the Adobe logo, Adobe Photoshop, Creative Suite and Illustrator are registered trademarks of Adobe Systems Incorporated.
Text and images copyright � 2000-2024 Photoshop Contest. All rights reserved. A venture of ExpertRating.com